City Council deliberation on facial recognition technology use in New Orleans
The New Orleans City Council is considering changes to its facial recognition ordinance amidst rising crime rates. This follows significant incidents including a violent attack and inmate escapes. Supporters advocate for enhanced police capabilities, while civil liberties groups express concerns over privacy and racial bias. As the debate continues, the council weighs public safety against the potential for surveillance overreach.
New Orleans – The New Orleans City Council is currently deliberating changes to an ordinance governing the use of facial recognition technology. This reevaluation comes in the wake of rising crime rates and a series of significant incidents, including a violent attack on Bourbon Street on New Year’s Day and the escape of ten inmates from the Orleans Justice Center.
Among the escapees are notorious individuals such as Antoine Massey and Derrick Groves, both of whom are still at large. Following these disruptive events, the recapture of inmate Kendell Myles marked a notable success for law enforcement. His identification was made possible through a facial recognition alert generated by Project NOLA, a local organization that runs a network of over 200 cameras throughout the city.
Project NOLA collaborates with various law enforcement agencies, including state police and federal agents, to enhance public safety. However, on April 7, NOPD Superintendent Anne Kirkpatrick ordered a suspension of facial recognition alerts for officers while the department reviews compliance with city ordinances. This pause has added urgency to the ongoing discussions surrounding the use of facial technology in law enforcement.
As crime rates escalate, the proposed changes would allow the New Orleans Police Department (NOPD) to utilize facial recognition technology more freely in emergency situations, bypassing the extensive oversight currently required under existing policy. Under the current framework, NOPD can only request a facial recognition analysis from Louisiana State Police when they have exhausted other investigative methods for specific violent crimes. If the changes are enacted, NOPD could act more swiftly, a shift that has garnered support from the NOLA Coalition, which consists of over 600 businesses and nonprofits advocating for advanced policing technologies.
Despite this support, civil liberties advocates are voicing strong concerns regarding the implications of enhanced surveillance capabilities. The ACLU of Louisiana, for instance, has called for a moratorium on the usage of facial recognition technology by NOPD. They highlight potential dangers, particularly the risk of establishing a surveillance state and the documented issues of racial bias associated with facial recognition systems, especially concerning misidentifications of Black individuals.
Critics point to previous reports that indicated limited effectiveness of facial recognition technology in NOPD’s operations. For example, in 2023, out of 19 requests made by NOPD, only one led to a successful identification. Conversely, supporters of expanding the technology emphasize demonstrable successes, including retracing the steps of suspects involved in the January vehicle attack on Bourbon Street.
Brian Lagarde, the founder of Project NOLA, claims that their facial recognition cameras are capable of identifying individuals from greater distances compared to city-controlled surveillance equipment. This disparity raises questions about compliance with local regulations and the overall transparency of surveillance practices in the city.
The debate underscores a broader issue involving the balance between public safety and the protection of civil liberties. As the New Orleans City Council continues its discussions, there is no clear timeline for potential amendments to the ordinance regarding facial recognition technology. Stakeholders, including law enforcement, civil rights groups, and the general public, are weighing the technology’s effectiveness against the potential for privacy violations.
As New Orleans navigates these complex issues, the outcome of these discussions will have significant implications for local law enforcement’s approach to tackling crime while respecting individual rights.
Eight Escapees Recaptured from Orleans Justice Center
Jailbreak in New Orleans Raises Concerns Over Safety
Nine Arrested in Orleans Justice Center Jailbreak Case
Mass Inmate Escape at Orleans Justice Center Raises Security Concerns
New Orleans Advances Ordinance to Protect Sex Workers
News Summary The sale of Entergy's gas distribution business to Delta Utilities has received final…
News Summary Governor Jeff Landry criticizes the oil and gas industry for hypocrisy as Louisiana…
News Summary The Louisiana Legislature is advancing Senate Bill 8, which seeks to transfer the…
News Summary Initial unemployment claims in Louisiana see a slight decrease to 1,986 for the…
News Summary Louisiana's clean energy sector, which has seen significant investment growth, is now at…
News Summary Louisiana lawmakers have passed a plan to allocate nearly $2 million annually from…